Guides / Drafting
How to leave a bad review for a business, honestly and calmly
Five steps
- Write down the facts first: date, amount, what was promised, what happened, and what you asked for.
- Gather what backs it up: receipt, invoice, messages, photos. You don't have to attach them; write as someone who has them.
- Draft it in your own words, in the order it happened. If you use the $19 pass's drafting studio, its suggestions come from an AI model, so don't use them for a Yelp review.
- Mark opinion as opinion. "In my experience…", "I would not use them again."
- Read it once more, then post it yourself on the platform you choose, following that platform's rules.
A review that doesn't get taken down is first-hand, dated, and itemized. Name the company, the date, the amount, and what you asked for. Mark opinion as opinion. Never state a crime as fact, never name staff, and never paste the same text on five sites. You post it from the account you already own.
No one can guarantee a review stays published. Platforms decide, and their rules change. Go Postl is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. You review, copy and manually post your own honest, first-hand account.
This page is write-time wording: how to write a review that doesn't get taken down, before you hit post. It is not how to appeal a takedown, and it is not legal advice. Go Postl does not create accounts, log in, or post for you. If the review is already gone, that is the process page. The copy-ready form is Template: Google review removed appeal.
Anchor every sentence to something you can prove
A date, an amount, a booking confirmation, a quoted promise. Moderators keep what they can check. A business trying to get it removed has less to argue with. Adjectives get deleted the first time a shop flags the post.
Write the transaction, not the mood. What you paid. When you paid it. What they said they would do. What arrived, or did not. What you asked for next, and whether anyone answered. If you have a quote, a text, or a booking email, say so. You do not need to attach it in the review. You need to write as if you still have it.
Google's Maps policy says posts "must be based on real experiences and information," and lists "Unsubstantiated allegations of unethical behavior or criminal wrongdoing" among the content it does not allow.
Signal opinion as opinion
"In my experience." "I felt." "I would not use them again." A reader should be able to tell which sentences are opinion and which are facts. Do not bury a conclusion inside a fact. Do not dress a fact up as a feeling.
If you cannot point to a receipt, a date, or a message, it is opinion. Mark it that way.
Never state a crime as fact
Fraud, theft, and scam are legal conclusions. Google lists unsubstantiated allegations of criminal wrongdoing among content it will remove. Describe what happened and let the next customer draw the conclusion. If the review is already gone, that is the removals guide, not this page.
Leave individuals out of it
Name the company, not the employee. Naming staff gets reviews stripped on most platforms and turns a business dispute into a personal one. Write "the manager on duty," not a first name and a face. What gets a review deleted or sued is in the ground rules.
How to write a bad review politely
Polite doesn't mean soft. It means the reader can trust you.
- Lead with what happened, not how you feel about the owner.
- Use the business's name, not an employee's. Write "the manager on duty."
- Skip insults, capital letters, and exclamation points. They make a true story read like a rant.
- Say what you asked for and whether anyone answered. "I asked for a refund on [date] and haven't heard back" is calm and hard to argue with.
- If they fixed part of it, say so. Credibility goes both ways.
Write it once, in your own words, per platform
Identical text pasted across five sites reads as a campaign to every spam filter. The same facts, written fresh each time, does not. Do not open a second account to dodge a filter. Do not use a tool to rewrite the same paragraph and post it again. Yelp's Content Guidelines say reviewers "shouldn't use third-party AI tools and chatbots to create reviews or other content, including using such tools to draft or revise content." That includes Go Postl's drafting studio, which uses an AI model. Write your Yelp review in your own words, and check each platform's own rules before you post.
Say what you wanted to happen
"I asked for a refund and got no reply" tells the next customer more about the business than any insult, and it is unarguable. A next step you actually took is a fact. A wish that they suffer is not.
Likely removed vs. fits the rules
Constructed example, not a customer story. Ridgeway Movers. $2,150 deposit paid 3 June for an 8 June pickup. No crew arrived. I asked for the deposit back on 10 June. No reply as of 23 June. If this was a move, the industry evidence list is one page on how to review a moving company.
Gets deleted: "Scam movers, they stole my deposit, Mike the dispatcher is a fraud. AVOID!!!"
Fits the rules: "I paid Ridgeway Movers a $2,150 deposit on 3 June for a pickup booked 8 June. No crew arrived. I asked for the deposit back on 10 June and have had no reply as of 23 June. In my experience they do not honor the booking they took money for."
Same facts. One names a crime and a person. The other names a date, an amount, and a request that sat unanswered.
Platform wording, not where to click
These are wording rules. They are not how to leave the review. That lives on the where-to-review pages.
Google. Keep it a genuine, first-hand account. No personal attacks, no crime stated as fact. See the prohibited-content list. How to leave a Google review is its own page.
BBB. Only the original consumer may leave a review. No anonymous reviews. You cannot also file a complaint on the same issue. How to leave a BBB review is its own page. If you want the Bureau to contact the business, that is a BBB complaint, a different filing.
A shop that tries to ban honest reviews in a form contract can run into the Consumer Review Fairness Act. The FTC Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule covers fake and suppressed reviews. CRFA kills gag clauses. It does not make every sentence immune to a challenge.
Already down?
If the review is already gone, use the process guide. For a paste-ready Google appeal, use Template: Google review removed appeal. This page will not tell you how to appeal.
Sources
Want the full version? The $19 pass adds a list of places this business can be reviewed (the BBB included), a drafting studio, an evidence locker for receipts and screenshots, and a dated log of what you posted. You read, edit and post every review yourself.
$19 for a year, billed every 12 months until you cancel.
First purchase: full refund if you ask within 14 days; access ends when we refund. After 14 days there is no refund. Yearly renewal charges are not refundable. We email you 30 days before each renewal. Cancel anytime by emailing djcaptkurt@proton.me and we cancel the same business day; your plan will not renew and you keep access until the end of the year you paid for.
Not a law firm. No outcome is promised.
The paid studio's suggestions come from an AI model.
Go Postl: honest reviews, properly filed. Not a law firm. Not legal advice.
Common questions
How long should a negative review be?
Long enough to cover what happened, when, how much it cost, and how the business responded. A few short paragraphs is usually enough.
Can I name the employee who served me?
Platform rules differ. Many discourage personal attacks and private details. Describe what happened and the role ("the manager") rather than targeting a person.
Is there a free tool to help me draft it?
Yes. The free Go Postl draft tool at /draft needs no account and builds the draft in your browser. You post it yourself.
No outcome is promised.