Skip to main content

Guides / Review risk

Can I get sued for leaving a bad review?

Honest reviews of what really happened to you are generally protected, and the Consumer Review Fairness Act stops contracts from gagging them. Trouble usually starts with claims you can't back up. Stick to dated facts and mark opinions as yours. We're not lawyers, and this isn't legal advice.

Can I get in trouble for leaving a bad review?

Who this is for

You had a bad experience with a business, you want to write an honest review, and you are worried about legal risk.

What makes a statement risky

According to Cornell LII's entry on defamation:

  • Defamation is "a statement that harms another person's reputation," and the precise elements "vary by jurisdiction."
  • The statement generally has to be "capable of being proven true or false."
  • "Statements of pure opinion are generally protected," but "merely characterizing a statement as an 'opinion' does not automatically protect it." A sentence framed as opinion can still be a problem if it implies a false fact.
  • "Defamation law varies substantially from state to state."
  • Historically, some categories have been treated as especially harmful, including "false statements accusing a person of committing a serious crime."

What that means for your wording: stick to what happened to you, with dates and amounts you can back up. Don't state a crime as fact. Let your opinion read as clearly yours. "In my opinion, the repair was poor" is different from "they're criminals".

What the Consumer Review Fairness Act does, and what it doesn't

From the FTC's guide to the Act:

  • The Act makes it illegal for a company to use a contract provision that "bars or restricts the ability of a person who is a party to that contract to review a company's products, services, or conduct," that "imposes a penalty or fee against someone who gives a review," or that requires people to give up their intellectual property rights in their reviews.
  • It covers "online reviews, social media posts, uploaded photos, videos," and also reviews of a company's customer service.
  • What it doesn't do: the FTC says it "doesn't apply to employment contracts or agreements with independent contractors." The law also says it's okay to prohibit or remove a review that contains confidential or private information, is "libelous, harassing, abusive," is unrelated to the company's products or services, or "is clearly false or misleading."

So the Act protects honest reviews from gag clauses. It does not make a false statement safe.

If a business threatens you

  • The FTC's Q&A on its Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule says a business "can threaten a legal action if you have a legitimate basis for doing so." The rule bars a business from using an "unfounded or groundless legal threat" to stop someone leaving a review or to get one removed.
  • The same Q&A says intimidation used to get a review removed "is not limited to physical threats."
  • If you get a demand letter or a cease-and-desist: keep a copy, don't reply in anger, and talk to a licensed attorney in your state. Go Postl can't advise on your situation.

How to write a review that lowers your risk

  1. Write only what you experienced first-hand.
  2. State facts you can prove: dates, amounts, receipts, messages, photos.
  3. Mark opinions as opinions, for example "In my opinion, the work was poor."
  4. Leave out guesses about motives, accusations of crimes, and other people's stories.
  5. Keep copies of your evidence and of the review you posted.
  6. If you receive a demand letter or cease-and-desist letter, keep a copy, don't reply in anger, and talk to a licensed attorney in your state.

Sources

Want the full version? The $19 pass adds a list of places this business can be reviewed (the BBB included), a drafting studio, an evidence locker for receipts and screenshots, and a dated log of what you posted. You read, edit and post every review yourself.

$19 for a year, billed every 12 months until you cancel.

First purchase: full refund if you ask within 14 days; access ends when we refund. After 14 days there is no refund. Yearly renewal charges are not refundable. We email you 30 days before each renewal. Cancel anytime by emailing djcaptkurt@proton.me and we cancel the same business day; your plan will not renew and you keep access until the end of the year you paid for.

Not a law firm. No outcome is promised.

The paid studio's suggestions come from an AI model.

Key terms

Common questions

Is a negative review defamation?

Defamation generally requires a false statement of fact that harms someone's reputation. A review built on true, first-hand facts and labeled opinion is a very different thing. Laws vary by state.

Can a contract stop me from leaving a review?

The federal Consumer Review Fairness Act makes many form-contract clauses that ban or penalize honest reviews void. There are exceptions, so ask a licensed attorney about your specific contract.

What should I do if a business threatens to sue me?

Keep the message, don't respond in anger, and speak with a licensed attorney in your state before you reply. Go Postl cannot advise on your situation.

Will Go Postl defend me or keep my review up?

No. Go Postl is not a law firm, and this is not legal advice. No one can promise a review stays up.

Go Postl is not a law firm, and this is not legal advice.

No outcome is promised.